It may have been a bad day for Gildersleeve, but it is an even worse one for the audience. Peary returns for the third time to the role that one can laugh at but not with. The dimwit becomes a jury foreman who refuses to believe that an obviously guilty gangster has done wrong--the only
one in the court still unconvinced. He redeems himself when, captured by gangsters and forced to drive their getaway car, he rams it into a tree to bring them to justice. This series was a spinoff of a popular radio show of the time.